Good Housekeeping's 2022 Home Renovation Awards
The excitement of home renovation can quickly turn to panic when you realize just how many products and materials go into the project. What’s the right countertop for the kitchen? Which fixtures will work best in the bathroom? Is now the time to switch to alternative energy? We get it! That’s why we launched the first ever Good Housekeeping Home Renovation Awards. Whether you’re planning a major remodel or just looking to simplify your home’s maintenance, you’ll find plenty of solutions in our roundup of winners.Take it from us: There is a lot happening in housing. Even before the pandemic, home improvement was a red-hot industry, with more millennials becoming homeowners and older Americans making upgrades to stay put in their existing homes. Then came COVID-19, and all those months stuck at home spurred even more activity, to the point where spending is now approaching half a trillion dollars a year, up from $300 billion in 2017.The surge in spending has prompted more R&D investment from manufacturers, hence the incredible array of building materials, systems, technologies and more on today’s market. But just because something is shiny and new doesn’t mean it belongs in your home. Enter the home pros at the Good Housekeeping Institute. Through more than 5,000 testing hours, our experts and consumer testers took a close look at the scores of submissions that poured into the Home Improvement & Outdoor Lab. Only products that will truly make your home better — whether easier to operate, more energy-efficient, safer, more stylish or some combination of them all — earned a place on our winners’ list.The picks are arranged by area of the house to help you sort through them ahead of your next big project.Meet the Judges Open GalleryHow We TestedOpen GalleryExperts at the Good Housekeeping Institute got hands-on with every product submission, often in more ways than one. In most cases, we started by calling in samples for Lab testing— for example, running stain and abrasion tests on countertops, decking and flooring. We also enlisted our army of consumer testers to evaluate products under the real-world conditions of their homes — say, running a digital air monitor for weeks on end or using a generator to power up appliances. Our Institute engineers also completed thorough reviews of technical data provided by manufacturers to verify claims around performance, safety, sustainability and more. Our home design editors, meanwhile, weighed in on style and aesthetics — for example, assessing the pattern of new tile or the palette of various siding materials. For added power tool insights, we brought in the expertise of Roy Berendsohn, senior home editor at Popular Mechanics, our partner publication; Roy and his team tested about a dozen tools at PM’s testing facility in Easton, PA. Finally, we teamed up with an outside judge, homebuilder, developer and author Fernando Pagés Ruiz, who installed an array of product submissions, from flooring to fixtures, on a new home build in Nebraska, then gave us his expert take on installation, performance and aesthetics. Kitchen All-Stars / Garage Wonders / Excellent Exteriors / Smartest Home Tech / Genius Home Monitors / Hottest Home Decor / Lawn & Yard Saviors / Perfect Power Tools / Biggest Energy Savers / Top Window Enhancements / Brightest Electrical Ideas / Best in BathKitchen All-StarsSpace-Saving Kitchen SinkDelta Faucet Workstation SinkOccupying one point of the kitchen work triangle along with the fridge and the cooktop, the kitchen sink is a prime piece of real estate that’s put to use only when you’re washing dishes, rinsing vegetables or doing some other faucet-focused activity. That’s why our design pros are huge fans of Delta’s new Workstation Sink with its bevy of space-saving accessories, from cutting boards to roll-up dish-drying racks. Available in a range of sizes and configurations, the sink can be retrofitted to just about any layout. It also comes in various materials, including stainless steel and an engineered composite that has the look of natural granite.Lab Results: Our Lab experts performed a thorough evaluation of the Workstation Sink. They were impressed by the quality of the sink itself, with its high-gauge stainless steel construction and soft-shoed bottom grid. The accessories, including the cutting board and drying rack, were also of top quality and fit neatly into the sink’s integrated ledge. “Especially in a small galley-style kitchen, this sink will be a serious space saver,” one tester noted. Sound-absorbing pads on the stainless stainless version we tested helped minimize noise and vibration, good for a sink that’s sure to see a lot of action. Top-Rated Countertop Cosentino’s Silestone Sunlit Days Quartz has become a favorite countertop material of our experts, thanks to its combination of beauty, durability and low maintenance requirements. Cosentinio’s version, called Silestone, boasts handsome hues and lustrous finishes, and that continues with Sunlit Days, its latest line of Mediterranean-inspired patterns. Cincel Grey, a fine-grained gray, plays to the trend around muted hues in the kitchen, while vibrant Cala Blue and verdant Posidonia Green are bold choices for homeowners feeling a little more adventurous. Beyond the alluring looks, there’s a sustainability angle to Sunlit Days, as the manufacturing process uses 99% reused water, 100% renewable electric energy and at least 20% recycled raw materials. Lab Results: Sunlit Days proved highly durable in our performance tests, shrugging off scratches, stains and heat. Our product experts also verified Cosentino’s claims around sustainability, like the use of renewable energy and recycled water. As for style, our design experts admired the subtle beauty of the color palette as well as the soft, luxurious feel of the suede finish.Indispensable Water DispenserElkay ezH2O Liv Built-In Water DispenserWe’d love to see plastic water bottles become a thing of the past. Innovations like the ezH2O Liv from Elkay are another step in that direction. The first ever built-in filtered-water dispenser designed for the home, the device is an ideal addition to a kitchen or mudroom where family members can refill their reusable water bottles before heading out for the day. The ezH2O Liv has a sleek look, thanks to its glass front panel (available in white or black) and brushed stainless steel alcove with LED light for nighttime hydration.Lab Results: The ezH2O Liv was among the products installed by Fernando Pages, our outside judge, in the laundry room/mudroom of his Nebraska new build. Pages confirmed that the station fit snugly between two wall studs, though he added that it would have been a tricky retrofit, as dedicated plumbing and electrical lines are needed. Once it was installed, he quickly embraced the utility of the station. “It’s the sort of accessory that seems indulgent at first, but after using it, the ease and speed of filling up a quart water bottle make it so convenient,” he said. We also like the familiar “Green Ticker” that counts the total number of plastic bottles kept from the landfill. Game-Changing FaucetKohler Crue Touchless FaucetCredit: Kohler Touchless technology is one of the latest innovations to hit the kitchen faucet, enabling users to turn the water on and off with a simple wave of the hand. That’s helpful if your hands are messy from meal prep, though the technology can be a little finicky, as you’ll probably know if you’ve used an airport restroom recently. The Crue addresses the pain point with the use of advanced motion-sensor technology for fast, reliable response times, says Kohler.Lab Results: We found the hands-free control on the Crue to be very effective. Plus, there’s still a lever handle for those who want to turn the water on and off the old-fashioned way. Based on our engineer’s review of the specs and technical data, we are assured of the quality of the faucet, including solid-brass construction, drip-proof ceramic disc valves and a durable finish. Using just 1.5 gallons per minute, the Crue also carries the EPA’s WaterSense label for water-efficient design.Ultimate Glass Cleaner Delta Faucet Glass RinserSome winners from this year’s awards program could save your life; others will just make it easier. The Delta Faucet Glass Rinser falls squarely in the latter category. Do you absolutely need one? No. Is it a clever kitchen sink accessory that lets you speed-rinse everything from water bottles to wine glasses? Absolutely! (No wonder it’s a favorite on TikTok, rinsing everything from glass beakers to empty dog food cans). Available in fingerprint-resistant stainless steel or chrome, the accessory can accommodate containers between 1 inch and 3.6 inches in diameter.Lab Results: We installed the Delta Rinser in a test kitchen at the Good Housekeeping Institute. We chose a sink that already had a side spray, which allowed us to take advantage of the existing water line. The powerful spray was great at rinsing all kinds of receptacles, including baby bottles and recyclables (though it’s not big enough for a 32-ounce yogurt container). The Rinser cleanly channeled water into the sink, and the stainless steel finish resisted smudges and water spots.Versatile Porcelain Tiles Crossville Porcelain Tile Panels by LaminamCredit: CrossvilleThis surface from Crossville combines two popular trends in home design: the use of porcelain (an extremely durable, beautiful and sustainable material), and large-format tiles (which create clean, contemporary interiors with minimal grout lines). Though the panels can be as big as 3.3 by 9.8 feet, they’re incredibly thin (3+ mm for vertical surfaces and 5.6 mm for floors), so they can be installed over existing tile or stone without the need for demolition. The panels come in a range of colors and patterns, from neutral beiges and grays to marble-inspired whites with deep veining.Lab Results: The porcelain panels excelled in our performance tests, proving extremely scratch- and stain-resistant. Despite their thin profile, they also withstood our tough drop test, designed to measure resistance to dents and chips. Our style experts love the large-scale dimensions of the panels and the diverse design palette should fit a wide range of home styles. Garage WondersSmart Garage Door OpenerChamberlain Secure ViewNow 25% OffSmart garage door openers add convenience and security by allowing you to open and close the door from anywhere—like the airport, for example, whereas before you’d have been in agony trying to remember if you locked up before leaving for vacation. The Chamberlain Secure View goes next level by integrating a Wi-Fi–connected camera so you can see inside the garage from anywhere too. The system also works with Amazon Key, enabling Amazon packages to be safely and conveniently dropped inside the garage.Lab Results: Chamberlain has been our top pick among smart garage door brands for years, thanks to the quality, reliability and versatility of its products. The Secure View maintains the same exceptional standard. Testers found the MyQ app to be highly intuitive, making it easy to open and close the garage door, set daily schedules and even share access to your garage with up to five users, which is especially helpful if you’re having work done on the house. The integrated light fixture provides bright illumination, and the camera is a welcome add-on that provides extra peace of mind, especially if you keep a lot of valuables in the garage. Tip-Top Tool StorageSquare D X and XD Series Wiring Device Credit: Schneider While smart plugs and lightbulbs allow you to control lighting and electronics remotely, for the best, most seamless connected home experience, you’re better off installing smart switches and outlets. Schneider Electric, a global manufacturer specializing in home automation and energy management, makes that prospect easier than ever with the launch of its Square D X and XD Series Wiring Devices. The collection includes connected switches, dimmers and outlets, many of which can be controlled through Schneider’s Wiser Energy app.Lab Results: Our engineers evaluated the assorted devices and found the materials and design to be top-notch, with the materials including heavy-duty plastic, tamper-resistant shutters and side-mount pressure plates for easy hookup. Installation was straightforward, though unless you have a lot of experience with electrical wiring we recommend hiring a professional. In terms of usability, testers liked the many specialty features, including the dual fast-charging USB ports on the Square D receptacle, the screwless face plates, and the ability to track energy consumption in real time through the Wiser Energy app. Best in BathBrilliant Bidet SeatKohler C3 230 Bidet Toilet SeatCredit: Kohler Bidet toilet seats make it possible to ditch the toilet paper in favor of a cleansing spray without having to replace your entire toilet. While manual bidet seats are available for as little as $100, our experts say it’s worth splurging on an automated model, especially if it’s Kohler’s C3 230 Bidet Toilet Seat. This bidet seats shows off Kohler’s innovation, with its sleek design, continuous warm water flow and adjustable settings, including oscillating and pulsating sprays. The seat even features an automated LED light, helpful for finding your way in the dark.Lab Results: Though bidet-style cleansing takes some getting used to, testers who tried out the Kohler say they’ll never go back to toilet paper. The adjustable cleansing sprays did the job on all body types and the built-in odor control was a hit. “I thought it might be gimmicky but the odor-neutralizing feature works surprisingly well,” one tester said. Another lauded the ergonomic design, saying: “A lot of bidet seats are steeply angled at the back because of the wires needed, and that can make them uncomfortable to sit on, but the C3 230 is really comfortable.”Top-Performing TilesLIVDEN Honeysuckle TileThese decorative terrazzo tiles were a fave of Monique Valeris, Good Housekeeping’s Senior Home Editor. “I love these!” she said. “It can be a challenge for brands to excel at both sustainability and good design, so I’m impressed that Livden does both well. “The energetic patterns and color combinations — the range of blues and pops of earthy orange tones — are very much on-trend.” Though we imagine the Honeysuckle Collection in a bathroom with a mid-century or art-deco flair, the 12 by 12-inch tiles are suited to any interior wall applications (Valeris loves them as a kitchen backsplash) or light-traffic floor.Lab Results: The terrazzo tile—a composite building material made from recycled glass, stone and binders—held up to our tough impact and abrasion tests. The slightly porous material was a bit more prone to staining (mustard gave it the most trouble) so our experts recommend vertical applications, or truly low-traffic floors. In terms of sustainability, our engineers reviewed the technical data to ensure that the tile base consists of at least 65 percent recycled material.First-Rate FlusherAmerican Standard Champion PRO ToiletThrough decades of toilet testing, American Standard has earned a reputation for performance and reliability with our experts. The Champion PRO two-piece toilet is up to the same standard. The 17-inch “comfort height” toilet is easy to get on and off, while its 1.28 gallons per flush is good enough for the EPA’s WaterSense label, awarded to the most water-efficient models. Everything needed for installation is included: tank, bowl, trip-lever, seat with lid, speed connect tank-to-bowl coupling kit, bolt caps and wax ring.Lab Results: Despite using very little water, the Champion PRO delivered impressive flushing performance in our tough tests, which included colored powder, wads of toilet paper, sponges and even golf balls. The flushing action also did a very good cleaning the bowl, which our testers say should reduce the number of manual toilet cleanings. Like all comfort height toilets, it’s easy to use, especially with the roomy, elongated bowl. Smart Shower ControlsKohler Statement Showering Collection + Anthem ControlsCredit: Kohler Smart home technology has made its way into bathrooms, where it adds convenience, functionality, safety and more. Case in point: this new high-tech shower system from Kohler. The Wi-Fi connected controls let you program precise temperature settings, which can be operated through the smartphone app, voice control, or through the touchscreen display. The shower system features an array of luxurious sprays, including an oblong showerhead and seven sprays, from deep massage to a full-body mist. Manual controls are available too, if you’re interested in the shower experience, but not the connectivity.Lab Results: Our design experts praised the fully-customizable configuration of the shower system, which allows for a truly unique walk-in shower experience. They also like the range of finishes—polished chrome, brushed nickel, matter black and brushed brass. The WiFi-connected controls are a neat convenience for high-tech homeowners. Builder Fernando Pages, our outside judge, installed the system successfully, though he cautions that it calls for 1-inch supply lines, unlike the 1/2-inch lines that are common in most homes.Sleek Shower DrainOatey QuickDrain ShowerLine Linear DrainCredit: OateyLinear drains bring a sleek, streamlined look to walk-in showers, which have become a preferred feature of luxury bathrooms. The drains are a safety upgrade too since they eliminate the need for a curb; that’s because the floor slopes gently in one direction, rather than from all four sides, as with a center drain. The biggest downside with linear drains is they have to be installed just right or the water won’t drain properly. Enter Oatey’s QuickDrain ShowerLine Linear Drain, an all-in-one kit that includes an integrated PVC drain, pre-sloped shower panels, and waterproofing accessories. The drain cover comes in a range of finishes, from brushed gold to matte black.Lab Results: Builder Fernando Pages used the Oatey system in his latest new home build. “My tile setter said the pan was extremely easy to install and said he would continue using the product on other jobs,” Pages reported. He also says the feature will appeal to buyers and add to the value of the home. “The pan looks very sharp, with a clean, modern appearance, while the drain cover compliments the other bath fixtures.” Our experts also like that the shower pan and panels are constructed from 100-percent post-consumer plastic water bottles. Illuminating Medicine CabinetKohler Maxstow Lighted CabinetCredit: KohlerBathroom lighting is easy to get wrong. In many homes, the fixtures are too high up, casting shadows that hamper makeup application, shaving and other grooming. Ideally, the light should be at eye level, which is what’s so ingenious about the Maxstow Lighted Cabinet. The side-integrated LED lighting washes the face in plenty of bright illumination. The mirror also provides excellent storage, with five staggered shelves for short and tall items. There’s even an internal electrical outlet for powering your electric toothbrush, razor or curling iron.Lab Results: Testers raved over the design of the mirror. “Incredibly sleek and stylish,” one wrote. “I love how the mirrored interior allows me to use my skincare products while the mirror is open, without having to take everything out.” The shelving and power outlet were also big hits. One caveat: the mirror was much harder to install than advertised, because of the complicated wiring involved. We strongly recommend professional installation.Having written thousands of product reviews and how-to articles on all aspects of home ownership, from routine maintenance to major renovations, Dan (he/him) brings more than 20 years of industry experience to his role as the director of the Home Improvement & Outdoor Lab at the Good Housekeeping Institute. A one-time roofer and a serial remodeler, Dan can often be found keeping house at his restored Brooklyn brownstone, where he lives with his wife and kids. More